Romance is more or less dead in studio movies—neither the romantic
comedy nor the romantic drama has remained a big-ticket item—but this
week it returns in “Fifty Shades Freed,” in a form that is best
summarized by a song from the Depression-era musical “Gold Diggers of
1937”: “Oh, baby, what I couldn’t do (ooh-ooh), with plenty of money and
you (ooh-ooh).” The last film in the trilogy is an alternately breezy
and tense tale of marital accord, conflict, and reconciliation, set
against a background of fabulous and seemingly effortless wealth and the
many difficulties that it poses.
The notion isn’t all facetious, either, not even in the slight, simplistic, utterly undeveloped paces through which the film puts its
newlyweds, Anastasia (a.k.a. Ana) Steele (Dakota Johnson) and Christian
Grey (Jamie Dornan). They escape from their lavish wedding
party and are whisked to a nearby airport, where they board Christian’s
private jet—or, rather, as he instantly reminds her, their private
jet. (Those new tax breaks will certainly come in handy.) What’s his is
hers, but, when they get home and Ana shows up at her office at the book
publisher Seattle Independent Press (ludicrously discovering that, in
her absence, she has been promoted to chief fiction editor), she
hesitates about making what’s his—namely, his name—hers. At home, to her
domestic staff, she’s Mrs. Grey (though she’d prefer to be called Ana),
but at work she wants to remain Ms. Steele, to keep her own working
identity and not convey the impression that she owes her position to her
husband (who has, in fact, bought the company—picking up on a gag from the second film in the series, he’s her boss’s boss’s boss). Christian,
discovering that she’s using the name Steele rather than Grey in her
office communications, has a hissy fit; then he gets over it.
Arriving home with Christian in his—sorry, their—sleek and vast
apartment occupying mansion-like terrain inside a modern high-rise
apartment building, Ana is taught the rules of the game: she can go
nowhere without a member of her security detail, because wealth and fame
make her a potential target of robbers and kidnappers. Daily life has
become complicated, and what she used to do effortlessly and
unthinkingly—going out, seeing friends, driving—is now a logistical
labyrinth (though, fortunately, there’s a chief of staff at home to keep
the system running smoothly). When the couple heads out to a remote old
lakeside house, Christian insists on taking their Autobahn-ready Audi,
which she’d like to drive. But first they’re met at the intricately
ramshackle old manse by an architect named Gia Matteo (Arielle Kebbel),
who flirts brutally with Christian. (The come-on line is an all-time
howler: “I love what you’re doing in Africa.”) In a moment alone
together, Ana gets her power moment and delivers it, putting Gia in her
place with a lacerating insult that only the high-handed rich patron
could get away with. The dispute, however, pivots not just on flirtation
but on architecture and its uses: Gia proposes to tear the house down
and is showing off her plans to rebuild a modern one on its site. But
Ana wants to keep and renovate the old house, maintaining its charm
while upgrading its facilities.
Such problems. Yet amid the blatantly empty fantasy is a scintilla of substance. What the Grey fortune suddenly offers Ana is the power
to do anything—it’s a sort of magic lantern that threatens to become a
tragic lantern. Tear a house down and rebuild? Sure. Fly to a distant
resort? Why not. Buy out a boutique’s stock of clothing? Certainly. But
head off unaccompanied to have drinks with a friend? Trouble awaits.
Take the wheel of a car and zip down a country road? A nefarious hot
pursuit ensues. (Ana, as it turns out, has 007-level evasive skills that
she casually displays in the moment of truth.) The subject of “Fifty
Shades Freed” is that the rich, as F. Scott Fitzgerald said, are
different—and that the introduction of the non-rich into their midst,
through marriage, is the only thing that keeps them tethered to the
ground like everyone else. But, in the process, the non-rich person
grafted into the wealthy family—even as she (or he) bends wealth toward
human ends—has to take on the burden of the new and constraining milieu,
has to bear up under the restrictions and limitations of wealth.
Fortunately, Ana faces up to the challenges brilliantly, albeit in a
plot twist that veers from the melodramatic to the grotesque. Keeping
spoilers to a minimum, it’s an unplanned pregnancy, which catapults
Christian into a quasi-adolescent crisis and threatens the marriage. But
resolution appears in the form of a villain ex machina, Jack Hyde (Eric
Johnson), Ana’s former boss, who threatens violence and whom Ana,
morphing from editor to vigilante, takes on alone, both bravely and
ingeniously. In effect, she takes one for the family, proving herself to
be a ferocious mother lioness and bringing Christian to his senses about
their unborn child.
The movie’s tone replicates its substance: the impersonally crafted,
emptily realized, expensively produced movie gets its modicum of humanity from
Dakota Johnson, who has the gift of simply seeming alive and present
when she’s on camera. Her expressions are mobile, a wry smile seems
always on the verge of breaking through the dramatic grind, and her
diction has a spontaneous and understated lilt that virtually cries out
for a substantial script and a director with agile powers of
observation. Dornan’s dry and inhibited performance, meanwhile, is a
mark of the director James Foley’s indifference—the actor was alert and
witty as Count von Fersen in Sofia Coppola’s “Marie Antoinette”
but is shrunken and stiff here.
Yes, there’s something to do with sex, too. Ana and Christian have a
spark in the bedroom (and the dining room and the car) that they keep
alight with what they do in the “playroom,” the luxuriously appointed
chamber in the apartment where their games of domination and submission
take place. Those games are now toned down; there’s tantalizing pleasure
but little pain; when it arrives, it’s in the form of Christian’s cruel and infantile “punishment” of Ana for her “disobedience”—for defying his orders regarding her
daily activities. And that’s interesting; the changes that have taken
place in the couple’s relationship are a noteworthy part of the movie, a
part that, however, isn’t addressed, discussed, hinted at, or dramatized
any more than any other aspect of their relationship. Despite being more
explicit than most romantic comedies or even dramas, the sex scenes in
“Fifty Shades Freed” are placeholders, signifying, in silence and by
means of a now-familiar exoticism, ordinary matters—the acceptable level
of sexual charge that holds marriages together and the way it shifts.
But, then, the entire movie, in a time with little cinematic romance, is
a placeholder.
Sourse: newyorker.com
